Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sharliegram's avatar

This is deplorable. We the people of the United States did NOT vote for this! You can have Trump, Vance, Musk! Take them please!

Expand full comment
Evan Þ's avatar

Declaring "supporting Russia" a crime "tantamount to treason" immediately makes me wonder just what things politicians will stretch to be "supporting Russia." I'm remembering how, just after Putin first invaded Ukraine, Russian emigres were often booed in the streets and fired from jobs even when they'd opposed Putin. Back then, a lot of people would consider employing a Russian person as "supporting Russia"!

Stretching this to include supporting "countries on the side of Russia" makes me even more worried, especially after your post has argued that the United States is now on the side of Russia!

For one example of how I can see this stretched - which has a lot of precedent in money-transfer laws: You offer subscriptions through Substack. Substack takes a cut of your subscription money. They're a United States company. Are you therefore "supporting" the United States? A country which you have just said is "on the side of Russia"?

I'm not indicting you for this at all. (I'm an American; I'd be hypocritical if I did!) What I'm arguing is that you should be a lot more precise when arguing to create new crimes. I support the Ukrainian cause too, but your advocating vague and dangerous new crimes detracts from your main case.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts